What a build! Not only did you guys made ACTUAL Tamahagane, you forged it as traditional as you can get these days. You did not disappoint. We waited, you delivered! All worth the wait. HATS OFF TO YOU! NOW THAT'S BLACKSMITHING!
Lol of course katana can’t cut through iron since a katana was built for speed when it comes to killing. Broad swords however, were a lot heavier may not be as sharp as a katana but uses its heavy advantage to deal blunt attacks. Thus, straining the opponent. Katana’s were made for ending quick fights, broadswords were made for long straining fights.
Very respectful of ancient and traditional Japanese culture and crafstmanship techniques. You are all saluted and did a great job Master Forgers right here.
I appreciate the effort and I think it's educational for those who don't know about Japanese forging techniques, but I was very disappointed that they decided to quench in oil instead of water. I understand that it's an easier to control process, but it does not give you the richness of a true Japanese Hamon.
@E.L. Norton They literally started red iron dust, and Ilya himself shows that he has done a remarkable amount of research into it - not just in this video but in subsequent ones. I think that they showed a completely proper amount of respect to the process.
I don't know how "respectful" it is. The forging of a katana in Japan is a spiritual and religious process and undertaking, from the production of the steel itself, to the blade, the polishing and the furniture. It takes months. To be respectful of the tradition would be not to awkwardly imitate it at all by reducing it to it a superficial process while completely missing the spiritual and cultural aspects of the process, the traditions and the lineage of the craftsmen that make a katana a katana. As Westerners do with all things, they miss the larger points to focus on the superficial in order to produce something they can jackass around with on TV. That is not respect.
fun fact: They have a lot Japanese sword forging videos (from anime fan request), but this is one of rare videos they respect ancient and traditional Japanese culture and crafstmanship techniques. if you watch another their kanata or nodachi forging video, you will see they don't forge in that way. not respect
I have an actual, from-a-swordsmith katana. On receiving it, I lashed a pool noodle to an Adirondack chair out in the yard. I took a straight, baseball-bat swing at the noodle and SWISH - it zipped through that noodle lightsaber style. A section of pool noodle maybe a foot long toppled off. I set it back up there and swung at that - ZIP - it cut through that loose, weighs-nothing, 1-foot piece of noodle as neatly as if it were attached to something. This is essentially a three-foot scalpel that can be swung like a bat. Every single metal surface is a facet, like the whole thing is a jewel.
Beautifully done. I was gifted a copy of “the craft of the Japanese sword” years ago and I obsessed over it. You really did it service here and brought the process to life.
@IPlayAnExpertOnTheInternet longswords perform better in every testing aspect apart from slashing. the inferior steel of the katana makes it a poorer quality sword too
@Wulf the technology is over 600 years old and is still being used today. Crucible's metallurgy has only gotten to where they are within the last decade. If you're trying to compare the two you already lost. Lmao. Edit - let me also add that aside from the inner and outter core of the blade itself, already explained in this video, the Katana's curve and even the fittings were all designed to absorb impact/reduce shock to the weilder. It is also perfectly balanced. All these in contrast to the European swords which are heavy one pieced and top heavy.
Imagine the will power and how many repeat-fail cycles it took until those guys perfected this stuff. Hundreds of years ago, without modern tools, without even a basic thermometer. This is one of the sides of Japanese culture I like the most, that constant drive for perfection in all areas of life.
This is there worst work, This katana looks NOTHING like the Kill Bill one, Not a damned thing, They spend all that time making a blade outta tamahagane And they cant even do the simplest fittings right, Just look at the fuchi n kashira, Hell the shape of the tsukae, Literally nothing but the tsuba looks similar.
(don't know what a weeb is anyway so who cares) also those who know the difference about swords are those who have the time and money to care about and buy completely useless items for our day and age. although they are cool, there really is no use. It is like buying an oddly shaped kitchen knife that you can't even use in the kitchen. Yes i don't know about swords but who cares, i sure don't and i just gave my honest opinion because yes katana really are a masterpiece among swords
@The Mad Hacker ...I know I am being childish/pedantic, as I am well aware of the mistake, but now I realy want to see an anime about Antro-Katanas wearing Katanas in a Steampunk-WWII-Setting.
Major respect for the amazing craftsmanship, not many can do this still. After saying that, they missed a few really important things. First it’s important to note that when heat treating and quenching, this is the moment the sword receives its soul. This is also the moment that the craftsman knows whether he will be able to continue with the piece or not as many crack during this process. And second the art of honing and polishing is one of the most important and most satisfying as you see the beauty of the blade come to life. Third they did not one single close-up of the blade once it was finished. And not one shot of the hamon which is the most awe inspiring part of any katana. I was very disappointed in the end because they didn’t show the beauty of their creation, only chopping objects like school children. I own a few beautiful swords and although I do enjoy chopping tatami mats, I appreciate them much more for their beauty. And I think after 1100 hours of hard labor they would want to show it.
I was very impressed by the level of respect that was given on following the traditions of making a Japanese katana, especially the techniques on making the damascus steel and the use of the leather and ray skin.
Firstly so much respect to Japanese tradition for sharing the process of making such a great sword with beauty, then I would like to thank to all persons who are from "Man at Arms" who they make this sword with such a dedication, and off course the camera man how can we forget him, such a great job done by all, so much respect and so much love from Bharat (India)🙏❤️🌱.
This episode is amazing! Great work, guys! It's lovely watching the more raw techniques of working the metal. Also, what's purpose of adding gold to the copper?
+Tony, The Stark Its most likely to make the copper an even stronger alloy as the gold is an alloy as its self as well so it makes it a much stronger handle
Absolutely Amazing! I try to follow sword making, but I had no idea just how much craftsmanship actually went into this beautiful sword! I'm speechless!
always wanted to see how a Japanese sword is made , so much goes into it , what a awesome job guys , would a typical soldier have a sword like this or would the armies of the times mass produce ones of lesser quality ?
These guys are true artists. I hope that the traditional smiths what originated this technique look upon this with approval. I would like to think they do or would as you can see and hear the respect in this build.
Unbelievable painstaking craftsmanship, echoing a period where taking one's time to produce a work of art was natural and normal. The camerawork wasn't bad either. Excellent work.
Awesome video. I watch a lot of modern-day forging shows but have always been curious how early ancestors actually created metals out of what's found in the ground. Now I know! Thanks!
I appreciate y'all going the traditional route forging of this blade, a whole new level of respect for you guys. I am curious if y'all are going to send it out to get it traditionally stone polished to further bring out the hamon and make it even more vibrant and sharp. The time and work put into this deserves the whole treatment. Good job.
Vinh Huynh They quenched it in oil, which will give just an equally good performing blade if it's a fast enough oil such as "Parks 50" from Heatbath, which they do have and do use. They went that route because there is MUCH less chance of the blade cracking in oil, and especially after all that work, I don't blame them lol , The blade will only curve up in a water quench, which is why they pre-curved it. Yea It's not 100% traditionally made, but close enough for this show's purpose, to entertain "along with" adding a bit of education here and there. :)
Richard Barbaros if you hold the menuki in the palm it gives you a better grip of the sword if your fingers rest on the menuki then it will be uncomfortable and weaken the strength of the grip on the handle.
That is one badass sword.wish i had one.the making of one really makes you wanna cherish it.thanks for showing us how those magnificent swords are made.
Very happy to see the forge lit the traditional way. I have a video describing that technique I watch regularly trying to learn all the terms involved, and seeing that element here was good.
This video is by far the best video from you guys! You guys have done your research...use proper terminologies...use the Japanese names...a bit of background info here and there. All your efforts results in this beauty of a sword! Absolutely STUNNING!!! Keep up the awesome work!!!
Defy Media makes the decisions on what goes on the build list. Nodachi and Odachi are fairly expensive to make though, and thus it would need to be a sponsored build.
True. But I personally am trying to have such involved builds be traditional. A telescopic "katana" is possible... but i am not using tamahagane for it.
Ilya Alekseyev although true it doesn't mean such an item/weapon cannot be created. Terminologies usually come after the idea has been realised...am I not correct to this extent? :)
Thoroughly enjoyed this video. How about doing the katana from the movie that through the dialogue spurred my interest into the Japanese sword making process and my fascination/love for the katana. Please and thank you. Love this series.
Really amazing and you used the traditional techniques which makes it so much cooler! My only complaint is some of the pronunciation of the Japanese but it was definitely better than most westerners lol
And to think people refused to see smiting as what it truly is...a beautiful artform that takes so much discipline. Much respect for all the smiths out there.
Keeping it educational. Wonderful job! You know, an interesting change of pace would be to try out a Chinese design, like a Jian... how about the Green Destiny from Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon?
Mind blowing - can barely (not) keep up with the hundreds of steps required to manufacture this weapon. Would love to know the evaluation of this work from a traditional Japanese bladesmith.
Crazy how much work was put into Samurai swords. As someone who doesn't know anything about blade...it's mind boggling how this was figured out from trial-error & then perfected. Just wild.
You guys should do the Yamato from Devil May Cry. It's build is basically the same as this blade, but the blade is also unique with it's gold and black guard and white rope wrapped hilt. You could also try making the scabbard, which as a loop for Vergil to tie a sash around, which he did. It was gold in DMC4:SE and dark blue in DMC5
LIved in Japan for 15 years, I would love to see a real Japanese sword maker critique this sword. I would be curios as to his opinion. Great job sword makers! True dedication to your craft!
I'm glad you smelted from ore and created your own steel for this build! Awesome and I'm sure purists give a big thumbs up calling it a traditional Japanese sword and actually going the hard way!!!
TheStalledPilot Your post was still readable, so it is by far, not the worst thing I've seen around these parts. I don't think that process would be feasable for the show though, as it would still require a fair amount of silver to give the final product a destinctive look. Perhaps they could do it with a high Chrome&Vanadium steel though.
Archer Witcher's silver swords are actually silver plated steel swords, so they could work with that to reduce costs. But yes, it would probably be pretty expensive. Still, I'd like to see it, even if they make it out of steel, swords from The Witcher are awesome looking!
So they could either just coat the cutting edge with silver, or damascus with some silver... Either way, it sounds like a proper challenge for the team.
I am passionate about the history of medieval Japan. I watched the birth of the katana with all my heart. congratulations boys. it is said that they have a soul and that they choose their masters.
My only issue with this, was due to the small size of the bloom. It had to be quickly welded under the hammer. But what should have been done is it should have been let to cool after the walls of the forge removed. So it could then be broken and sorted into high carbon and low carbon shards which would then be stacked and welded. Giving a more controlled placement of high and low carbon steel as opposed to the relatively random placement from a bloom taken directly from forming to weld.
As always Ilya and the team have made a beautiful piece of art Going to be honest tho Matt is my favorite and then Ilya is my second favorite. He was so close but not quite there
This is a art that no many have I enjoyed the whole video brothers you have amazing skills I am completely absorb by your videos thakyou this sword is priceless and gorgeous
A fraction of all kinetic energy is always converted into thermal energy. Thats why rubbing your hands together heats them up, or why you get rope burn.
![Making Tanjiro's Katana from [Demon Slayer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/V7swQ2qWJPE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Making Tanjiro's Katana from [Demon Slayer]](/img/tr.png)
What a build! Not only did you guys made ACTUAL Tamahagane, you forged it as traditional as you can get these days. You did not disappoint. We waited, you delivered! All worth the wait. HATS OFF TO YOU! NOW THAT'S BLACKSMITHING!
That's just anime malarkey.
@Unknown Entity You better consult some historical books on STEEL, You may be surprised at the date when steel was made.
I am sorry. Sorry that this reply section has turned into people saying that katanas can cut through armour...
Yeah loved that traditional pneumatic power hammer
Lol of course katana can’t cut through iron since a katana was built for speed when it comes to killing. Broad swords however, were a lot heavier may not be as sharp as a katana but uses its heavy advantage to deal blunt attacks. Thus, straining the opponent. Katana’s were made for ending quick fights, broadswords were made for long straining fights.
Very respectful of ancient and traditional Japanese culture and crafstmanship techniques. You are all saluted and did a great job Master Forgers right here.
I appreciate the effort and I think it's educational for those who don't know about Japanese forging techniques, but I was very disappointed that they decided to quench in oil instead of water. I understand that it's an easier to control process, but it does not give you the richness of a true Japanese Hamon.
@E.L. Norton They literally started red iron dust, and Ilya himself shows that he has done a remarkable amount of research into it - not just in this video but in subsequent ones. I think that they showed a completely proper amount of respect to the process.
I don't know how "respectful" it is. The forging of a katana in Japan is a spiritual and religious process and undertaking, from the production of the steel itself, to the blade, the polishing and the furniture. It takes months. To be respectful of the tradition would be not to awkwardly imitate it at all by reducing it to it a superficial process while completely missing the spiritual and cultural aspects of the process, the traditions and the lineage of the craftsmen that make a katana a katana. As Westerners do with all things, they miss the larger points to focus on the superficial in order to produce something they can jackass around with on TV. That is not respect.
fun fact: They have a lot Japanese sword forging videos (from anime fan request), but this is one of rare videos they respect ancient and traditional Japanese culture and crafstmanship techniques. if you watch another their kanata or nodachi forging video, you will see they don't forge in that way. not respect
Nicolas Liberatori wym?
Wow, he sliced through that foam noodle as if it were a foam noodle
@MalumInSe it's a joke
I have an actual, from-a-swordsmith katana. On receiving it, I lashed a pool noodle to an Adirondack chair out in the yard. I took a straight, baseball-bat swing at the noodle and SWISH - it zipped through that noodle lightsaber style. A section of pool noodle maybe a foot long toppled off. I set it back up there and swung at that - ZIP - it cut through that loose, weighs-nothing, 1-foot piece of noodle as neatly as if it were attached to something. This is essentially a three-foot scalpel that can be swung like a bat. Every single metal surface is a facet, like the whole thing is a jewel.
@TakeMeHome but they made a 5 dollar china knife did they?
why would test a china knife where they made a fine ass katana
nope! it is spagetti
You should try this with the sharpest knife or sword you think you have...lol. foam noodle...
Beautifully done. I was gifted a copy of “the craft of the Japanese sword” years ago and I obsessed over it. You really did it service here and brought the process to life.
This is why these swords are worth so much. Loads of work and effort put into them. Much respect!
@IPlayAnExpertOnTheInternet longswords perform better in every testing aspect apart from slashing. the inferior steel of the katana makes it a poorer quality sword too
@ChromaFox science has proven that they only need two folds for the japanese katanas instead of 20 and using modern day steel is better anyway
@Chelu cheaper ones are mass produced with rougher materials and methods, ones from 5,000 upwards are hand crafted high quality
@IPlayAnExpertOnTheInternet lmao what an ignorant comment. you probably also think katanas can cut through tanks xDD
@Wulf the technology is over 600 years old and is still being used today. Crucible's metallurgy has only gotten to where they are within the last decade. If you're trying to compare the two you already lost. Lmao.
Edit - let me also add that aside from the inner and outter core of the blade itself, already explained in this video, the Katana's curve and even the fittings were all designed to absorb impact/reduce shock to the weilder. It is also perfectly balanced.
All these in contrast to the European swords which are heavy one pieced and top heavy.
Imagine the will power and how many repeat-fail cycles it took until those guys perfected this stuff. Hundreds of years ago, without modern tools, without even a basic thermometer. This is one of the sides of Japanese culture I like the most, that constant drive for perfection in all areas of life.
Possibly the best work they've ever done.
Illya, you're a damn machine, it's clear to me you love your craft deeply.
i agree amazing work.
Nate Davies
ล
ล
This is there worst work, This katana looks NOTHING like the Kill Bill one, Not a damned thing, They spend all that time making a blade outta tamahagane And they cant even do the simplest fittings right, Just look at the fuchi n kashira, Hell the shape of the tsukae, Literally nothing but the tsuba looks similar.
(don't know what a weeb is anyway so who cares) also those who know the difference about swords are those who have the time and money to care about and buy completely useless items for our day and age. although they are cool, there really is no use. It is like buying an oddly shaped kitchen knife that you can't even use in the kitchen.
Yes i don't know about swords but who cares, i sure don't and i just gave my honest opinion because yes katana really are a masterpiece among swords
I love the thought of an old Japanese smith going to the traditional POWEERR HAMMMERRR!!
@The Mad Hacker The Katana swords carried in WW2 did have a ceremonial aspect but they were fully functional swords.
@The Mad Hacker ...I know I am being childish/pedantic, as I am well aware of the mistake, but now I realy want to see an anime about Antro-Katanas wearing Katanas in a Steampunk-WWII-Setting.
also, katanas were carrying katanas even into WW2. though there were mostly ceremonial at that point
It’s the most traditional tool on hand if you think about it
美しい波紋、再現する一つ一つの細かい工程、イリヤさんは天才
Major respect for the amazing craftsmanship, not many can do this still. After saying that, they missed a few really important things. First it’s important to note that when heat treating and quenching, this is the moment the sword receives its soul. This is also the moment that the craftsman knows whether he will be able to continue with the piece or not as many crack during this process. And second the art of honing and polishing is one of the most important and most satisfying as you see the beauty of the blade come to life. Third they did not one single close-up of the blade once it was finished. And not one shot of the hamon which is the most awe inspiring part of any katana. I was very disappointed in the end because they didn’t show the beauty of their creation, only chopping objects like school children. I own a few beautiful swords and although I do enjoy chopping tatami mats, I appreciate them much more for their beauty. And I think after 1100 hours of hard labor they would want to show it.
I was very impressed by the level of respect that was given on following the traditions of making a Japanese katana, especially the techniques on making the damascus steel and the use of the leather and ray skin.
Firstly so much respect to Japanese tradition for sharing the process of making such a great sword with beauty, then I would like to thank to all persons who are from "Man at Arms" who they make this sword with such a dedication, and off course the camera man how can we forget him, such a great job done by all, so much respect and so much love from Bharat (India)🙏❤️🌱.
This episode is amazing! Great work, guys! It's lovely watching the more raw techniques of working the metal.
Also, what's purpose of adding gold to the copper?
+Pearce Sampley chutya thats what it is called alloying element..
+Supernova Gaming gold isn't an alloy... it's an element
+Tony, The Stark Its most likely to make the copper an even stronger alloy as the gold is an alloy as its self as well so it makes it a much stronger handle
+Tony, The Stark to make copper shine.
Holy gorgesness
Absolutely Amazing! I try to follow sword making, but I had no idea just how much craftsmanship actually went into this beautiful sword! I'm speechless!
Love how this build stayed as close to the traditional ways as possible.
always wanted to see how a Japanese sword is made , so much goes into it , what a awesome job guys , would a typical soldier have a sword like this or would the armies of the times mass produce ones of lesser quality ?
Ilya is the traditionalist that’s why he’s immersed in his work :3 I love Ilya he’s cool
He's a very nice person, and very easy to talk to. Most people don't believe that English is his third or fourth language.
Wow. . .you guys are amazing. . .I'd love to have a sword made from you to be displayed. I am not sure if I can afford it but really work of art.
Ilya is definitely my favorite bladesmith. Wow! I had no idea he was so knowledgeable about his craft. Amazing!
No surprise he actually won a Forged In Fire competition.
Illya vs Michaelcthulu in terms if giant swords
Mine too... Unbelievable talent, and very respectful and knowledgeable of the traditional ways... That takes years and years of practice.
These guys are true artists. I hope that the traditional smiths what originated this technique look upon this with approval. I would like to think they do or would as you can see and hear the respect in this build.
This is honestly my favorite episode y’all have done
Unbelievable painstaking craftsmanship, echoing a period where taking one's time to produce a work of art was natural and normal. The camerawork wasn't bad either. Excellent work.
Oh man ! this has to BE THE BEST EVER sword making I have seen ! Ilya and Matt are geniuses at what they do !!
Awesome video. I watch a lot of modern-day forging shows but have always been curious how early ancestors actually created metals out of what's found in the ground. Now I know! Thanks!
I appreciate y'all going the traditional route forging of this blade, a whole new level of respect for you guys. I am curious if y'all are going to send it out to get it traditionally stone polished to further bring out the hamon and make it even more vibrant and sharp. The time and work put into this deserves the whole treatment. Good job.
Vinh Huynh They quenched it in oil, which will give just an equally good performing blade if it's a fast enough oil such as "Parks 50" from Heatbath, which they do have and do use. They went that route because there is MUCH less chance of the blade cracking in oil, and especially after all that work, I don't blame them lol , The blade will only curve up in a water quench, which is why they pre-curved it. Yea It's not 100% traditionally made, but close enough for this show's purpose, to entertain "along with" adding a bit of education here and there. :)
Richard Barbaros if you hold the menuki in the palm it gives you a better grip of the sword if your fingers rest on the menuki then it will be uncomfortable and weaken the strength of the grip on the handle.
mercilessv also changing the sheath to better reflect it since the one they use is bills sheath and not the brides.
mercilessv Green Destiny from Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon!
Playbahnosh The "soul of the sword", the best way to describe it, ever.
That is one badass sword.wish i had one.the making of one really makes you wanna cherish it.thanks for showing us how those magnificent swords are made.
Very happy to see the forge lit the traditional way. I have a video describing that technique I watch regularly trying to learn all the terms involved, and seeing that element here was good.
I love how true to Japanese sword making processes you were. Thank you for your dedication! ありがとうございます!
There's so much work and craftmanship for just one sword, its insane. No wonder Katanas are so popular
I appreciate the time that was taken to research the proper traditional methods to forge this awesome sword. Thank you
This felt less like watching you guys make the Kiill BIll sword and more like watching you guys just make a sword and I absolutely loved it!!!
I wish this was even longer I would watch this stuff for hours while I do scale modeling!!
Absolutely stunning! Wonderful craftsmanship!
Great looking blade . Very impressive watching you guys building the sword.
These men really care about their craft. I respect it
gorgeous craftsmanship.
not just the sword, but the process.
This video is by far the best video from you guys!
You guys have done your research...use proper terminologies...use the Japanese names...a bit of background info here and there.
All your efforts results in this beauty of a sword!
Absolutely STUNNING!!! Keep up the awesome work!!!
Fingers crossed!! :)
Defy Media makes the decisions on what goes on the build list. Nodachi and Odachi are fairly expensive to make though, and thus it would need to be a sponsored build.
I agree! Then would you consider making a Nodachi?
True. But I personally am trying to have such involved builds be traditional. A telescopic "katana" is possible... but i am not using tamahagane for it.
Ilya Alekseyev although true it doesn't mean such an item/weapon cannot be created. Terminologies usually come after the idea has been realised...am I not correct to this extent? :)
Thoroughly enjoyed this video. How about doing the katana from the movie that through the dialogue spurred my interest into the Japanese sword making process and my fascination/love for the katana. Please and thank you. Love this series.
I didn’t think watching a sword be made would be so entertaining
Really amazing and you used the traditional techniques which makes it so much cooler! My only complaint is some of the pronunciation of the Japanese but it was definitely better than most westerners lol
Great Work! Would it be possible to make a traditional Roman Centurion's Sword?
And to think people refused to see smiting as what it truly is...a beautiful artform that takes so much discipline. Much respect for all the smiths out there.
Keeping it educational. Wonderful job! You know, an interesting change of pace would be to try out a Chinese design, like a Jian... how about the Green Destiny from Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon?
I second that. Or even Sky's spear from Hero.
im not super in to polearms but I really watch anything man at arms makes as long as its not the combination weapon things. I hate those.
Shut-In Spaceman how about Guan Yu's Polearm. That thing is wicked.
im down for zuko's dao
Stephen Kostes
OH RIGHT! I forgot he had those!
This guy’s knowledge of Katana are absolutely well over the knowledge of it that ordinary People who live in Japan have.
Phenomenal.
These guys aren't just bladesmiths ..they are true, real deal, artist
Mind blowing - can barely (not) keep up with the hundreds of steps required to manufacture this weapon. Would love to know the evaluation of this work from a traditional Japanese bladesmith.
Super cool! Love seeing it go from dust to blade
Crazy how much work was put into Samurai swords. As someone who doesn't know anything about blade...it's mind boggling how this was figured out from trial-error & then perfected. Just wild.
This is by far the coolest Man at Arms. Great work, folks.
You guys should do the Yamato from Devil May Cry. It's build is basically the same as this blade, but the blade is also unique with it's gold and black guard and white rope wrapped hilt. You could also try making the scabbard, which as a loop for Vergil to tie a sash around, which he did. It was gold in DMC4:SE and dark blue in DMC5
This might be the best sword they have ever made as far as effort, durability, and sharpness.
Quite simply the greatest sword ever created. And the most beautiful.
Great craftmanship and creativity guys keep it up
You guys made this sword maybe even more traditional as the Japanese themself nowadays :D
There's something about katanas made in a Japanese traditional style that is just purely beautiful to watch, awesome video, wish it was longer
this is absolutely a majectically done katana its so freaking majestic
LIved in Japan for 15 years, I would love to see a real Japanese sword maker critique this sword. I would be curios as to his opinion. Great job sword makers! True dedication to your craft!
I'm glad you smelted from ore and created your own steel for this build! Awesome and I'm sure purists give a big thumbs up calling it a traditional Japanese sword and actually going the hard way!!!
wouldve been better if they used higher quality steel
You guys did a great job with the japanese techniques considering it takes guys a lifetime to master that.
Very impressive work, outstanding know how and a piece of art sword. Congratulations and many thanks.
This episode was a treat.
Witcher steel sword and silver sword combo? Interested to see if you can actually make a silver sword properly.
Shirokurou Or: Zireael (Ciri's sword) made out of steel and the "hole" in it would be something new on this chanel.
They used gold in a small amount in this very episode, so maybe they can have some silver in it.
TheStalledPilot Your post was still readable, so it is by far, not the worst thing I've seen around these parts. I don't think that process would be feasable for the show though, as it would still require a fair amount of silver to give the final product a destinctive look. Perhaps they could do it with a high Chrome&Vanadium steel though.
Archer Witcher's silver swords are actually silver plated steel swords, so they could work with that to reduce costs. But yes, it would probably be pretty expensive. Still, I'd like to see it, even if they make it out of steel, swords from The Witcher are awesome looking!
So they could either just coat the cutting edge with silver, or damascus with some silver...
Either way, it sounds like a proper challenge for the team.
Exelente video, sobre todo por respetar el método tradicional para realizar la mejor espada que se ha hecho hasta ahora. 😉😉😉
This is real cool. I wanna see an episode we’re they follow tradition western techniques like they did with the eastern ones in this
This might be my favorite project these guys have worked on
simply beautiful. the work, crafting and the end result.
I have watched many of your videos and I love watching you all work together.
Perhaps the best episode yet!
Well-done!
still my favorite video to date. i always rewatch kill bill
I could truly watch this all day wish I knew the securities to making great swords
I am passionate about the history of medieval Japan. I watched the birth of the katana with all my heart.
congratulations boys. it is said that they have a soul and that they choose their masters.
What a beautiful technique and final product, congratulations!
Awesome job sirs and using the Japanese tradition.
Congratulations! 🤩
That sword is priceless. But in El Paso it's worth $250.
@Daniel Lima who? The guy who got bit by the snake?
Tbf, he didn't actually sell it. It probably would have gone for more
Cheap Economy, won't stand a single blow!
@Patrick Hayes
What?
@Hazardous 088
Truly remarkable.
I even liked the history lesson.
Respect for these beautiful workmanships
I don’t know how many times I’ve watched this video.😂 it would be a dream come true make a katana, or even watching 😂
using the old fashioned way , that was a very nice touch and shows how much you respect the craft , great work
Hattori would be proud....WOW! Beautiful...just beautiful, nothing like it. It's like the sword has life inside it.
Can you make more long episodes like this please
I wonder if they can make the 3-blade staff from a Sho Kosugi film Revenge of the Ninja. The stick that can be a Spear, Sword and Dagger.
My only issue with this, was due to the small size of the bloom. It had to be quickly welded under the hammer. But what should have been done is it should have been let to cool after the walls of the forge removed. So it could then be broken and sorted into high carbon and low carbon shards which would then be stacked and welded. Giving a more controlled placement of high and low carbon steel as opposed to the relatively random placement from a bloom taken directly from forming to weld.
So appreciat to see you made The Katana on the way of original Japanese 's swordsmith.
So nice to see hand craftsmanship these days, with anything.
Hearing protection when hammering. It's one modern advancement that should be role modeled in great videos like this one.
By far the best episode yet. Hypnotic. Liked, favourited etc.
genuine question, is it going to be as good as a traditional katana from the sengoku era?
Wonderful, no words to describe more ❤️❤️❤️❤️
we heard you wanted us to use more traditional methods, so we went ahead and rebuilt the entire workshop out of bamboo for this build
As always Ilya and the team have made a beautiful piece of art
Going to be honest tho Matt is my favorite and then Ilya is my second favorite. He was so close but not quite there
I forgot it was a kill bill video and I’ve watch this like three times already. Great work
I think this is my favorite episode by far. I really enjoyed the attention to detail and traditional techniques.
Ron Butner ,
Ragnar Danneskjold I agree
Ragnar Danneskjold ManAtArms should build gohan's first sword
My favourite Ilya/Sam build ...
玉鋼から精製、鍛錬の工程、柄巻きに至るまで、素晴らしい。
I love finding chemistry videos that I can show to my kids to capture their attention. You have made awesome videos in that regard. Thanks!
Wow I finally found a video of sword crafting with actual English so I can understand the steps. Great video. Looks amazing
This is a art that no many have I enjoyed the whole video brothers you have amazing skills I am completely absorb by your videos thakyou this sword is priceless and gorgeous
You can actually make steel red hot just by striking it with hammer?? Man, I just learned something new today...
@Getsum Chuck Norrise also forges metal with his bare hands
@Tomás Pabón Chuck Norris makes the rope catch fire when he slides down it.
A fraction of all kinetic energy is always converted into thermal energy. Thats why rubbing your hands together heats them up, or why you get rope burn.
this might have been the most fascinating episode yet. watching these traditional techniques at work is something beautiful.
This was awesome such a beautiful art.
Respect. Congratulations on an outstandingly successful production. Curious, what was the final weight?
Beautiful sword lads. Keep up the good work. Next project the Dragon Sword from Ninja Gaiden 2 please.